Armed Forces in Alphabetical Order [archive]

An enormous global pet peeve since Digital Music collapsed from long unsegmented strings of PCM into inodes on a filesystem is Armed Forces in Alphabetical Order. The first ID3 spec, meant to associate the audio-only information in the MPEG stream with some โ€œreal worldโ€ characteristics, was pitiful: audio gets 1MB per minute but the concordant ground truth was allowed only 128 bytes. We allowed 30 for artist, 30 for album, 30 for song title, 30 for โ€˜comment,โ€™ four for year, three for a header, and one tiny byte for genre (I guess they got one thing right, anyone who ever disagreed with me on the futility of genres need only to glance at the original genre specification, which thoughtfully included an entry for โ€œPrimus.โ€ It looks like they had room for about 108 more artists, I could have given them an ordered list.)

I can deal with a song called (Whatโ€™s So Funny โ€˜Bout) Peace but I could never brook the destruction of the album order. My 2000 Nomad Jukebox software sometimes added track numbers to the beginning of the file name but it was a rock tumble if my various plastic MP3CD players would latch onto that helpful clue. The worst bit is that it would always trick you: sometimes filesystems would put the โ€œ(Whatโ€™s So..โ€ at the end, so youโ€™d start with the normal Accidents Will Happen, pleased with the world. But instead of Senior Service youโ€™d then hear Big Boys, and you knew there was some engineer staring at a hex editor who never, and I promise never, had any romantic trouble or maybe in general just hated music?